Evolution
The human body is built around starch
By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com
Our genes and our gut show a long history of eating plants, especially starch[1][2][3]. We can’t make our own vitamin C[1], our saliva starts breaking down starch before we even swallow[3], and cooked carbohydrate is the most plausible fuel for the growing human brain[5]. And today, the people who eat no animals have the lowest risk of several major diseases.
We can’t make our own vitamin C
Most mammals make their own vitamin C[1]. Drouin, Godin and Page (Current Genomics, 2011) describe how anthropoid primates, humans included, along with guinea pigs and some bats, carry a broken GULO gene and can’t make ascorbic acid[1]. It has to come from food[1]. Fresh meat is a poor source, and fruit and leaves are the reliable ones[1]. Losing that gene is only harmless if the diet keeps supplying the vitamin, so our ancestors must have kept eating plants[1].
We start digesting starch in the mouth
Human saliva contains amylase, the enzyme that starts breaking down starch while food is still in the mouth[3]. Perry and colleagues (Nature Genetics, 2007) found that humans carry more copies of the salivary amylase gene, AMY1, than other primates do[2], and that people from populations with high-starch diets carry even more[2]. So our genes adapted to starch rather than to a meat-only diet[2].
Further down, Milton Mills puts the human gut at roughly ten to eleven times the length of the body, closer to other plant-eating primates than to the short digestive tract of a cat[3]. Some people point to stomach acid as a sign that we’re meat eaters. Beasley and colleagues (PLOS ONE, 2015) put the baseline pH of the human stomach at about 1.5[4]. In their table, the other mammal with a stomach that acidic is the rabbit, a herbivore[4], though scavengers as a group still had the most acidic stomachs on average[4]. Stomach acid mainly works as a filter against pathogens, and it doesn’t mark humans as hunters[4].
Humans turned grain and roots into porridge, rice, bread and cooked tubers, and the world’s staple foods are still starches: rice, wheat, corn, potatoes and beans[5].
Cooked starch likely fueled the growing human brain
The human brain uses a lot of glucose[5]. Hardy and colleagues (Quarterly Review of Biology, 2015) argue that cooked starch supplied that glucose directly[5]. People ate meat too, but their analysis finds brain growth less plausible without the energy from carbohydrates[5]. This fits Wrangham’s argument that cooking is a human biological trait[6]: heat turns many plant foods that are too fibrous to eat raw into usable fuel[6]. The extra AMY1 copies Perry found would have helped the body get the most out of that starch[2].
Vegans have the lowest risk of several major diseases
People who eat no animals have the lowest risk of heart disease in pooled analyses, less cancer overall in a 2026 review that called the vegan evidence limited[8], and the lowest risk of type 2 diabetes in the Adventist Health Study-2[9]. Ornish’s vegetarian trial reversed plaque in the coronary arteries[10], and no diet that includes meat has done that in clinical trials. Li and colleagues (2025) linked processed meat with a higher risk of dementia[11], and in one observational study, vegetarians had the lowest dementia risk of the diet groups compared[12]. Vegetarians have also come out ahead in endurance tests, including the old ones at Yale.
The mental health studies are mixed
A 2025 meta-analysis in Nutrition Reviews covering 709,703 adults found that in cohort studies, the healthiest plant-based diets came with a 23% lower risk of depression[13], while unhealthy plant-based diets came with more depression and anxiety[13]. A 2021 analysis pooling 13 studies and 49,889 people found that vegetarians scored higher on depression than non-vegetarians, though the results varied a lot between studies[14]. An umbrella review of the reviews found that most showed no link or conflicting results[15]. It also noted that the depression could come first, since people who are already struggling may change how they eat[15]. A 2026 review in Frontiers in Nutrition found a similar split: healthy plant-based eating went with fewer depressive symptoms, ultra-processed plant foods with more, and studies of vegetarians and vegans specifically came out both ways[16].
Most of these health studies are observational, and they describe how people do today rather than what our ancestors ate. Still, they fit a primate that needs plants for its vitamin C[1], starts digesting starch in its mouth[2][3], and does well on a plate of plants.
Sources
[1]Drouin et al., 2011
Current Genomics, 2011
[2]Perry et al., 2007
Nature Genetics, 2007
[3]Mills, comparative anatomy
Mills, comparative anatomy essay
[4]Beasley et al., 2015
PLOS ONE, 2015
[5]Hardy et al., 2015
Quarterly Review of Biology, 2015
[6]Wrangham, 2003
Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology, 2003
[7]Heart-disease review
[8]Cancer, Am J Clin Nutr
[9]AHS-2 diabetes
[10]Ornish reversal
[11]Li et al., dementia
[12]Vegetarian diets and dementia
[13]Plant-based diets and mental health
Nutrition Reviews, 2025
[14]Vegetarian diets and depression scores
Journal of Affective Disorders, 2021
[15]Depression umbrella review
Nutrition Reviews, 2025
[16]Plant-based diets and depression review
Frontiers in Nutrition, 2026