Pesticides

Pesticides

If you cared about pesticides, you would stop eating farm animals.

2,000×legal glyphosate limit on animal feed vs many human foods

According to the EPA’s glyphosate residue tolerances in 40 CFR 180.364, nongrass animal feed may carry 400 ppm of glyphosate, and grass, hay, and other forage 300 ppm. In contrast, many human foods are capped at 0.2 ppm[1], meaning animal feed is allowed 1,500 to 2,000× more of this pesticide[1]. Not to mention, about 80% of our agriculture is used for farm animals[4], and in the U.S. alone, feed crops take up about 75% of cropland[8] and get about 235 million pounds of herbicides and insecticides sprayed on them in a single year[2]. If you cared about insects and pesticide use, you would stop eating animals.

What the evidence says

The main points first. Every claim is tied to a source below.

Animal feed is legally allowed 2,000 times more glyphosate than many human foods

The EPA’s own glyphosate table, 40 CFR 180.364, allows 400 parts per million on nongrass animal feed (group 18)[1]. Many human foods on the same table, including artichokes, stone fruit, and leafy vegetables, are capped at 0.2[1]. Divide 400 by 0.2 and you get 2,000[1], so the crops grown to fatten farm animals are allowed 2,000 times more of this pesticide than crops for human food[1].

Switching to grass-fed doesn’t help. The same table sets grass forage, fodder, and hay (group 17) at 300 parts per million[1], which is 1,500 times the limit on those human foods[1].

These are the official U.S. residue limits[1], not a campaign estimate. If you care about how much poison is allowed on food, look at the feed.

Read full article →

Most pesticide spraying goes on crops grown for farm animals

In 2018, World Animal Protection and the Center for Biological Diversity counted about 235 million pounds of herbicides and insecticides sprayed on U.S. factory-farm feed crops[1], including about 100 million pounds of glyphosate[1].

Corn and soy account for about half of all pesticide use in the U.S.[2], and people don’t eat most of that harvest themselves[2]. Around the world, about 80% of soy[3] and about 61% of corn are fed to farm animals[2], and in the U.S., most soy and about a third of corn are used as feed[4]. Eating animals means growing their feed first and then losing most of it in the conversion to meat, so the spraying happens on all those extra acres.

Read full article →

About 80% of agricultural land is for farm animals

Poore and Nemecek found that farm animals take up about 80% of agricultural land[1] while supplying only a minority of the world’s calories. In the U.S., feed crops take up about 75% of cropland[2].

So people who worry about pesticides on their vegetables have it backwards. The fields sprayed on an industrial scale are corn, soy, and hay grown for farm animals. A vegan diet doesn’t need that land, or the spraying that goes with it[2].

Read full article →

If you cared about insects, you would stop eating farm animals

Spraying glyphosate on Midwest corn and soy wiped out the milkweed in those fields, and losing that milkweed is a main reason monarch butterflies have declined[1]. The EPA’s own evaluation found that glyphosate is likely to harm a large majority of the protected species it studied, including plants, insects, fish, and others[2]. Those corn and soy fields are this big because farm animals eat what they grow. Eating plants directly takes a fraction of the land, and so a fraction of the spraying. If you’re worried about insects, eating animals is the bigger problem.

Read full article →

Articles

Most pesticide spraying is for farm-animal feed

Corn and soy get about half of all the pesticides used in the U.S., and most of that harvest is fed to farm animals. EPA rules even let nongrass animal feed carry 2,000 times more glyphosate than many human foods.

Read full article →

Sources

Papers and datasets. Each card keeps its caveats, including small samples and single-animal cases.

[1]eCFR / 40 CFR 180.364 · Review

The EPA’s glyphosate limits (40 CFR 180.364)

The EPA allows 400 ppm of glyphosate residue on nongrass animal feed (crop group 18), but only 0.2 ppm on artichokes, many fruits, leafy vegetables, and other human foods, so the feed limit is 2,000 times higher. Grass forage, fodder, and hay (group 17) are allowed 300 ppm, or 1,500 times the 0.2 ppm limit.

[2]Center for Biological Diversity / World Animal Protection, 2022 · Review

About 235 million pounds of pesticides were sprayed on U.S. feed crops in 2018

World Animal Protection US and the Center for Biological Diversity found in their 2022 report, “Collateral Damage,” that about 235 million pounds of herbicides and insecticides were sprayed on U.S. crops grown to feed factory-farmed animals in 2018, including about 100 million pounds of glyphosate.

[3]Faunalytics, 2023 · Review

About 49% of U.S. pesticides go on corn and soy, mostly grown for feed

Faunalytics reports that corn and soy take a large share of U.S. pesticide use, with about 49% of pesticides applied to those two crops alone, and most of that harvest goes to animal feed.

[4]Science, 2018 · Meta-analysis

Farm animals use about 80% of farmland but supply a minority of calories

Poore and Nemecek found that farm animals use about 80% of agricultural land while supplying only a minority of the world’s calories. If the whole world ate vegan, farmland would shrink from about 4.1 billion hectares to about 1 billion.

[5]WWF · Review

About 80% of the world’s soy is fed to farm animals

WWF says about 80% of the world’s soy is used as farm-animal feed rather than eaten by people.

[6]U.S. EPA · Review

The EPA found glyphosate is likely to harm most endangered species it studied

The EPA’s national-level evaluation found that glyphosate is likely to harm a large majority of the endangered and threatened species it studied, including plants, insects, fish, and other wildlife.

[7]Environmental Research Letters, 2017 · Observational

Glyphosate on corn and soy helped drive the monarch butterfly decline

Thogmartin and colleagues found that the loss of milkweed in Midwestern farm fields, driven largely by glyphosate sprayed on corn and soy, is a major factor in the decline of monarch butterflies.

[8]PNAS, 2018 · Review

Feed crops take up about 75% of U.S. cropland

Feed crops take up roughly 75% of U.S. cropland. Without farm animals, most of that land wouldn’t need to be planted and sprayed to grow feed.