Land

A vegan world would need about 75% less farmland

By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com

If everyone on Earth ate a plant-based diet, the world would need about 75% less farmland[1]. Our World in Data, using Poore and Nemecek’s 2018 study in Science, puts today’s agricultural land at about 4.1 billion hectares and a plant-based world’s at about 1 billion[1][2]. That frees up roughly 3 billion hectares, an area on the order of North America plus Brazil, which could go back to forest and wild habitat[1]. It takes so much land because to eat animals, we first have to grow plants for them, and most of what an animal eats never comes back as food.

Most farmland feeds animals

Farming already covers about 44% of the world’s habitable land, around 48 million square kilometers[3]. About 80% of that farmland is used for meat and dairy, either as pasture or as cropland that grows feed[3]. For all that land, meat and dairy supply only about 18% of the world’s calories and about 37% of its protein, Poore and Nemecek found[2]. The rest of the world’s calories and protein come from plants grown on the remaining fifth.

Most of the food is lost inside the animal. A cow, pig or chicken spends most of the energy in its feed just staying alive, and only a small share becomes meat, milk or eggs. Cow flesh is the worst: it gives back only a few percent of the protein the animal was fed[4]. In a 2013 paper in Environmental Research Letters, Cassidy and colleagues measured farm output as the number of people fed per hectare, rather than tons harvested[4]. By that measure, shifting crop calories from animal feed to people would feed more people on each hectare[4], because a large share of the world’s crop calories never reach a human plate[4]. They’re fed to animals first[4].

Where the 75% figure comes from

The 75% comes from Our World in Data, working from Poore and Nemecek’s global analysis[1][2]. That analysis found that meat and dairy take the vast majority of farmland[1][2] and produce about 60% of agriculture’s greenhouse gases[2], and that avoiding them is the single biggest way to cut the impact of what you eat.

Springmann and colleagues got a similar number a different way[5]. Their 2018 paper in Nature modeled how the food system could stay within planetary boundaries for land use, climate and other limits[5]. They found that without a shift toward plant-based diets, the food system couldn’t stay within the land-use and climate boundaries, even with improvements in how food is produced[5]. In their analysis, fully plant-based diets cut global land use by something on the order of 70%[5].

Most of the land a vegan world would free up is pasture, and the rest is cropland that now grows feed[2]. People would still need cropland, but much less of it, because the crops would feed people directly instead of going through an animal first.

Wild animals were pushed off the land

Giving most of the world’s farmland to animals[3] has changed which animals live on Earth. If you weigh every mammal that isn’t human, about 94% of the total is cows, pigs and other farm animals, according to Our World in Data’s figures from Bar-On, Phillips and Milo’s 2018 census of life on Earth in PNAS[6][7]. Farm animals outweigh wild mammals about 15 to 1[6][7], and on land alone their share is 97%[6]. Wild animals were pushed out to make room for animals bred to be killed. Forests are still being cleared for the same reason[8]. Drawing on Pendrill and colleagues, Our World in Data puts beef at about 41% of tropical deforestation, the largest share of any product, in the tropics where most forest is cleared[8].

The exact figure depends on the model

Both numbers come from global models, and the exact figure depends on their assumptions: about 75% in Our World in Data’s estimate[1] and on the order of 70% in Springmann’s[5]. Some grazing land is too dry or steep for crops, so not every hectare of freed pasture could become a field. It could go back to forest, grassland or wetland instead, and that’s the goal. Neither estimate depends on new technology or higher yields[1][5]. The land comes back because the animals no longer need to be fed.

Sources