Growth

Children grow normally on a planned vegan diet

By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com

Children raised on a planned vegan diet grow normally[1][2][4][5][6]. Two large German studies, one of toddlers and one of school-age children, found height and weight in the normal range[1][2] and less obesity than among children who ate meat[2]. Reviews of the research agree[3][4], and the professional bodies for dietitians in the US, Canada and the UK say a well-planned vegan diet is appropriate at every stage of life, including pregnancy and infancy[8][9][10]. The key word is “planned,” and the one study that found vegan children slightly smaller[7] shows why.

Vegan children in Germany grew normally

The VeChi Diet Study (Weder and colleagues, Nutrients, 2019) measured 430 German children aged 1–3 who ate vegan, vegetarian or omnivorous diets, using three-day weighed food records and standard growth charts[1]. Median height-for-age, weight-for-age and weight-for-height didn’t differ between the groups, and more of the meat-eating toddlers were overweight[1]. A small share of the vegan and vegetarian toddlers were classified as stunted[1], so although the typical child grew normally, energy intake and care still matter for the children at the edges.

VeChi Youth (Alexy and colleagues, Nutrients, 2021) followed 401 children and teenagers aged 6–18[2]. The vegan children still met protein recommendations, grew within the normal range and were less often obese[2]. Alexy’s 2023 review in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health, which covered studies published from 2018 to 2023, found height and weight mostly similar in children who ate meat and children who were vegetarian, with lower fat mass among the vegetarians[3].

Reviews and older studies found normal growth too

Sutter and Bender reviewed nutrient status and growth in vegan children in Nutrition Research in 2021[4]. Apart from a small percentage of outliers, the vegan children grew normally and were less often obese[4]. The nutrient gaps they found showed up when B12, iodine, calcium or calories were left to chance[4]. An analysis of vegan infants also found normal growth when the diet was planned[5].

One of the largest studies of vegan children comes from The Farm, a community in Tennessee, where O’Connell and colleagues measured 404 children, most of them vegan[6]. Their height and weight were close to the U.S. reference curves (Pediatrics, 1989)[6]. The study is old, and vitamin and mineral supplements were common in the group[6].

Vegan children in Poland were a little smaller

Desmond and colleagues compared 52 vegan, 63 vegetarian and 72 omnivore children aged 5–10 in Poland (American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2021)[7]. On average, the vegan children were a little shorter and lighter and had lower bone mineral content, but they also had a healthier cardiovascular risk profile[7]. The size difference is real, and it’s a reason to plan calories, calcium and B12 carefully, not a reason to feed children animals[7].

Dietitians say a planned vegan diet suits every age

In 2009 the American Dietetic Association said appropriately planned vegetarian diets, vegan diets included, are healthful, nutritionally adequate and appropriate at every stage of life, naming pregnancy, breastfeeding, infancy, childhood and adolescence, as well as athletes[8]. The American group, now called the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, repeated that position in 2016[9]. The British Dietetic Association says carefully planned plant-based diets can support healthy living at every age and life stage, that all the essential nutrients can come from plants, and that vegans need a reliable source of B12[10].

The NHS says that with good planning, a varied vegan diet can give the body what it needs, including for people who are pregnant or breastfeeding and for children, with fortified foods or supplements for B12 and a few other nutrients[11]. Mayo Clinic says a well-planned vegetarian diet can suit people of all ages, including during pregnancy and breastfeeding, and that vegans need to plan for B12, calcium, iron, zinc, iodine and omega-3[12]. When papers warn against vegan diets for children, they’re usually describing unplanned ones, with B12 skipped or too few calories[4][9].

Some nutrients people assume children have to get from animals can come from plants. Vitamin A is one: the body makes it from the carotenoids in plants, and even most people who convert them less efficiently can cover their needs with more plant sources or a modest supplement[14]. Growing children don’t need liver or milk to get it.

Sources