Brain
Cooked starch fueled the growth of the human brain
By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com
A lot of people think eating meat made humans smart, but starch is the better explanation[1][2][4]. Humans carry a genetic adaptation for digesting starch that other apes lack[4][5], the foods that feed most of humanity are grains, tubers and pulses[9][10], and researchers who study human evolution argue that glucose from plants, above all cooked starch, fueled the brain as it grew[1][2]. Plenty of other animals eat meat, and none of them became as smart as us.
The brain runs on glucose
Hardy, Brand-Miller, Brown, Thomas and Copeland laid out the case in the Quarterly Review of Biology in 2015[1]. Cooking starch greatly increased the energy reaching the body’s glucose-hungry tissues, the brain most of all, and they argue that plant starches were essential during the Pleistocene, when the brain was expanding[1]. Our ancestors did eat meat[1]. So do hyenas, wolves and orcas, and none of them grew a 1,350-gram brain.
In 2026 Brand-Miller, Hardy, Copeland and colleagues came back to the question in Science, modeling the human body’s glucose needs going back four million years[2]. Sugars from fruit and honey came first, then pounded and cooked starch once people were using fire[2]. As the University of Sydney explained in its coverage of the paper, raw starch doesn’t release glucose, so early humans probably relied on sweet plant foods until cooking made tubers and grains usable[3]. After that, cooked starch from wild yams and similar plants added to the supply[3]. The authors conclude that glucose was essential for the human brain, which means carbohydrate foods belong in the explanation for our bigger brains as much as animal foods do[2].
Both papers are reviews and modeling studies, not experiments, and nobody can run a controlled trial on human evolution[1][2]. Their case rests on how the body works and on what our genes and the world’s diets show.
Our genes adapted to starch
In 2007 Perry and colleagues reported in Nature Genetics that humans carry on average about three times as many copies of AMY1 (the gene for salivary amylase, the enzyme in saliva that breaks down starch) as chimpanzees do, and about six to eight times as much of the protein, with still more copies in populations who eat more starch[4]. Behringer and colleagues (PLOS ONE, 2013) measured the enzyme in bonobos, chimpanzees, gorillas and orangutans, not in humans, and found higher baseline levels in gorillas and orangutans than in chimpanzees and bonobos[5].
Humans have no comparable gene expansion for digesting raw flesh[4]. The enzymes that break down protein, pepsin and trypsin, work on protein from any food, plants included, and plant-eating animals make them too. Without tools, cooking and seasoning, flesh is hard to chew and mostly bland. Our genes changed to handle starch[4], and it took a kitchen to make meat easy to eat.
Stomach acid doesn’t make us carnivores
Some people point to stomach acid as proof that humans are built for meat. Beasley and colleagues (PLOS ONE, 2015) found that human stomach acid is about pH 1.5, and in the same dataset, the rabbit, a plant-eater, has a stomach about as acidic[7]. Scavengers as a group have the most acidic stomachs[7], and cats are around pH 3.6. Strong stomach acid alone doesn’t make a species a carnivore[7]. Milton Mills, writing on comparative anatomy, points to our grinding molars, our lack of the shearing carnassial teeth that cats have, a small intestine that is long compared with a cat’s, and a colon built to hold plant bulk[8].
Most people live on grains, tubers and pulses
The UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) lists the foods most people live on as rice, wheat, maize, millet, sorghum, potatoes, cassava and yams[9]. Rice, maize and wheat alone provide about 60% of the world’s food energy[9], and starchy staples, pulses included, supply most of the calories for most of humanity[10]. No other animal lives mainly on cooked grains and tubers[10].
Most smart animals don’t live on meat
If eating meat were what built intelligence, most of the animals we call smart would be meat-eaters. Sentient Media put together a widely shared list of 30 animals often called the most intelligent[11]. It’s journalism, not a scientific ranking[11], but it works as a rough check. Only about seven of the 30 eat almost nothing but animals: dolphins, octopuses, cats, orcas, wolves, hyenas and Portia spiders[11]. About eleven eat almost nothing but plants: elephants, African grey parrots, pigeons, horses, squirrels, bees, deer, llamas, koalas, gorillas and giraffes[11]. Chimpanzees, bonobos and orangutans, also high on the list, get the vast majority of their calories from plants[11].
Eating meat doesn’t explain intelligence in other animals[11], and humans evolved extra starch genes and still live mostly on starchy staples[4][9][10].
Sources
[1]Hardy et al., QRB 2015
Quarterly Review of Biology, 2015
[2]Brand-Miller et al., Science 2026
Science, 2026
[3]University of Sydney, 2026
University of Sydney, 2026
[4]Perry et al., 2007
Nature Genetics, 2007
[5]Behringer et al., 2013
PLOS ONE, 2013
[6]Smithsonian, tools
[7]Beasley et al., 2015
PLOS ONE, 2015
[8]Mills, comparative anatomy
Mills, comparative anatomy essay
[9]FAO, staple foods
FAO
[10]FAO, food energy
FAO
[11]Sentient Media, 30 animals
Sentient Media