Endurance

Plant-based diets give endurance athletes an edge

By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com

People who eat plants have at least as much endurance as people who eat meat[2][3][4][5], and when the trials are pooled, the plant eaters come out ahead[1]. A 2024 meta-analysis found a moderate boost to aerobic performance on plant-based diets with no cost to strength[1]. Studies of recreational runners find that vegans race just as fast[3]. And in one of the earliest recorded comparisons, at Yale in 1907, the meat-eaters were beaten badly[8].

Plant-based diets improved aerobic fitness

Damasceno and colleagues pooled the trial data in a 2024 paper in the British Journal of Nutrition[1]. Plant-based diets had a moderate positive effect on aerobic performance, with an effect size of 0.55 (95% CI 0.29–0.81), and no effect on strength or power, up or down[1]. So an athlete who switches to plants has no reason to expect to lose strength, and some reason to expect better aerobic capacity[1].

Boutros and colleagues (European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2020) compared 56 healthy, young, lean women who trained the same amount each week, 28 of them vegan and 28 omnivores[2]. The vegan women had a higher estimated VO2 max, and their muscle strength was no different[2]. The study was observational, so it can’t separate the diet from anything else the vegan women did differently, but nothing in it suggests their food held them back[2].

Vegan runners race just as fast

The NURMI study (Wirnitzer and colleagues, Nutrients, 2023) looked at recreational distance runners[3]. Once differences in training were accounted for, best half-marathon and marathon times weren’t significantly different between omnivores, vegetarians and vegans[3]. Nebl and colleagues (Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2019) tested ambitious recreational runners on vegan, lacto-ovo-vegetarian and omnivorous diets, found no significant difference in exercise capacity, and concluded that a vegan diet can be a suitable alternative[4].

Stanford’s SWAP-MEAT Athlete study (Roberts and colleagues, Nutrition Journal, 2022) put recreational athletes through three diets, one after another: a whole-food plant-based diet, a diet built on plant-based meat alternatives, and an animal-based diet[5]. Their performance didn’t drop on either plant diet, though each phase lasted only four weeks[5]. Keeping pace with omnivores is already enough to disprove the claim that you need meat to go the distance[4], and the meta-analysis suggests plants add something on top[1].

Why plants may help

Barnard and colleagues reviewed plant-based diets for endurance sports in Nutrients in 2019[6]. Plant-based diets improve blood fats and blood flow, and their carbohydrate refills the glycogen that fuels long efforts[6]. In the research they reviewed, a mostly vegan vegetarian diet cut visceral fat and raised VO2 max even without weight loss[6]. In a marathon, the heart is often what limits a runner, and plant-based diets tend to be good for the heart. For people who run long distances, recovery and heart safety matter too[6].

Pohl and colleagues (Nutrients, 2021) came to a similar view: the macronutrient mix of vegan and vegetarian diets, with plenty of carbohydrate and antioxidants and benefits for the lining of the blood vessels, has potential advantages for endurance, and research hasn’t shown a consistent penalty[7]. Craddock’s 2016 review of older trials had found that vegetarian diets neither helped nor hurt performance[7]. It took the newer meta-analysis to find an advantage[1][7].

Yale’s meat-eating athletes lost badly in 1907

Irving Fisher tested about 49 people in three groups: Yale athletes who ate meat, athletes who avoided flesh, and sedentary vegetarians from Battle Creek who were physicians and nurses[8]. He published the results in the Yale Medical Journal in March 1907[8].

In a test of how long each person could hold their arms out, the meat-eaters averaged about 10 minutes, and the flesh-abstainers lasted about five times as long[8]. Only two of the fifteen flesh-eaters held out past 15 minutes, compared with twenty-two of the thirty-two abstainers[8][10]. Not a single meat-eater reached half an hour[8][10]. Fifteen of the abstainers did: nine went past an hour, four past two hours, and one past three hours, reaching 200 minutes[8][10]. The best of the meat-eaters, a football guard, gave up at 22 minutes[8][10].

In deep knee-bends, the meat-eating athletes averaged about 383 and the plant-eating athletes about 927[8]. The sedentary vegetarians, who spent most of the day sitting, averaged about 535, which still beat the Yale athletes who ate meat[8]. One person who had never eaten meat did 2,400 and then went back to nursing duties[8][10].

Fisher wasn’t a vegetarian[8], and he wrote that the results came “much to my surprise[8].” He concluded that the flesh-eating athletes were “very far inferior in endurance to the abstainers, even the sedentary group.”[8] On March 22, 1907, The New York Times reported that Yale’s flesh-eating athletes had been beaten in severe endurance trials, under the headline “Vegetarians the Stronger[9].”

The study was small and old, and holding your arms out or doing knee-bends is nothing like a modern VO2 lab test[8]. NutritionFacts’ account of the early research also describes an 1896 Vegetarian Cycling Club and a 1904 Belgian lifting test in which the plant-eaters reportedly managed about 80% more repetitions, though the English primary source for the Belgian test is hard to find[10]. Fisher’s numbers are the ones that survive in the archives[10], and more than a century later, the 2024 meta-analysis found the plant eaters ahead too[1][8].

Sources