Mortality

Plant protein is linked with a longer life, and animal protein is not

By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com

People who get more of their protein from plants die at lower rates than people who get it from animals[1][2][5]. Researchers have found this in pooled data on more than 700,000 people[1], in decades of follow-up on American nurses and health professionals[5], in the NIH-AARP cohort[4] and among Adventists[6]. More plant protein is linked with lower all-cause and cardiovascular mortality[1][2]. Animal protein shows no such protection[1][2], and meat, especially red and processed meat, is linked with more deaths[4][5].

The largest studies favor plant protein

The largest analysis is a dose-response meta-analysis published in the BMJ in 2020[1]. Naghshi and colleagues pooled data on 715,128 people and found plant protein linked with lower all-cause and cardiovascular mortality[1]. The more plant protein people ate, the lower their death rate[1]. Animal protein didn’t show that protection[1].

A 2020 analysis in the European Journal of Epidemiology combined the Rotterdam cohort with pooled data from other cohorts and found the same thing[2]. Higher plant protein intake went with lower all-cause and cardiovascular mortality[2], animal protein showed no matching benefit[2], and the authors took the result as support for shifting protein from animals to plants[2].

A 2022 systematic review in Nutrients gathered substitution studies in older adults, which ask what happens when one source of protein replaces another[3]. Swapping animal protein for plant protein was linked with lower cardiovascular mortality and less type 2 diabetes[3].

Swapping animal protein for plant protein meant fewer deaths

Substitution models come closest to the question most people are actually asking. Huang and colleagues used the NIH-AARP cohort, reported in JAMA Internal Medicine in 2020, to estimate the effect of replacing animal protein with plant protein[4]. The swap was linked with about 10% lower overall mortality, in both men and women[4]. The researchers measured the swap in steps of 3% of energy, which is just a unit of measurement, not a recommended stopping point[4]. The drop was bigger when the protein being replaced came from eggs or red meat[4]. The benefit comes from the swap itself, so nothing in the results argues for stopping at a small one[4].

Song and colleagues came at the question differently and reached the same conclusion[5]. Using decades of data from the Nurses’ Health Study and the Health Professionals Follow-up Study, they found higher animal protein intake linked with higher mortality, especially in people who already had a risk factor, and higher plant protein intake linked with lower mortality[5]. Most of the extra risk from animal protein came from red meat[5]. How much protein people ate didn’t explain the difference; where it came from did[5].

Vegetarians had lower death rates

The Adventist Health Study-2 compares diets within a single community[6]. Orlich and colleagues followed 73,308 Adventists and reported in JAMA Internal Medicine in 2013 that vegetarians as a group had 12% lower all-cause mortality than nonvegetarians, a hazard ratio of 0.88[6]. Pesco-vegetarians came in at 0.81[6]. Vegans came in at 0.85, but the confidence interval of 0.73 to 1.01 just crosses 1.0, so the vegan result on its own isn’t statistically significant[6]. The clearest links were with deaths from cardiovascular disease, kidney disorders and endocrine disease, including diabetes, and the association was stronger in men[6].

Adventists tend not to smoke in the first place[6], which removes one of the biggest confounders in diet research. Even in a group that health-conscious, leaving meat off the plate still went with fewer deaths[6].

Dinu’s 2017 meta-analysis in Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition found vegetarian diets linked with fewer cases of ischemic heart disease and cancer[7]. Its pooled estimate for vegan all-cause mortality was a relative risk of 0.88, in line with AHS-2, but it rested on only two cohorts and had a wide interval, so that specific question is still open[7].

Switching to chickens doesn’t help

A lot of people who cut back on red meat just eat more chicken flesh instead. In a competing-risk analysis published in Nutrients, eating more than 300 g of chicken and turkey flesh a week was linked with higher all-cause mortality and higher mortality from gastrointestinal cancer[8]. Like the other studies here, it’s observational, and it doesn’t support the idea that chicken flesh is a safe middle ground[8].

These are observational studies

All of these studies are observational, or pool data from observational studies. People who eat more beans and less meat differ from other people in ways that adjusting for smoking, weight and exercise can only partly capture. The vegan-specific estimates, from AHS-2 and from Dinu, are imprecise and don’t settle the question on their own[6][7].

But the studies agree with each other. Adventists[6], American health professionals[5], NIH-AARP participants[4], the Rotterdam cohort[2] and 715,128 people in pooled data[1] all show the same thing: more plant protein goes with fewer deaths[1][2][4][5], and animal protein, especially from animal flesh and eggs, doesn’t add any years[1][2][4][5][8]. We can get the protein we need from plants, along with a longer life[1][2][4][5], and no animal has to be killed for it.

Sources