Animals
Scientists say we are not the only conscious animals
By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com
In 2012, a group of neuroscientists met at the Francis Crick Memorial Conference in Cambridge and declared that, by the weight of the evidence, humans aren’t unique in having the brain structures that generate consciousness[1]. All mammals and all birds have them too, they wrote[1].
Twelve years later, scientists went further. The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness, published at NYU in 2024, says there is strong scientific support for conscious experience in mammals and birds[2], and at least a realistic possibility of it in all vertebrates, fish included[2], and in many invertebrates. It also sets out a practical rule: when there’s a realistic possibility that an animal is conscious, it’s irresponsible to ignore that possibility in decisions that affect them[2]. Every animal farmed for food on a large scale, from cows and pigs to chickens and farmed fish, is covered by the declaration[2].
The declarations don’t claim certainty
Both declarations are statements by scientists summing up research that already exists. They aren’t new experiments, and they don’t claim to know exactly what it’s like to be a hen or a trout. The New York Declaration picks its words carefully: “strong support” for mammals and birds[2], and a “realistic possibility” for other vertebrates[2].
But the declaration doesn’t ask anyone to be certain before acting[2]. It says the possibility alone is enough to take into account[2], and for the animals we farm, there’s far more than a possibility.
Scientists keep finding minds in the animals we eat
Cows recognize their own calves by voice[3]. In playback experiments published in Animal Behaviour in 2016, mothers were more likely to look, turn or walk toward a recording of their own calf than toward an unfamiliar one[3], and calves did the same for their mothers[3]. In another study, heifers who learned to solve a task reacted more strongly at the moment of success, in heart rate and behavior, than cows who got the same rewards for nothing[4], a sign that they notice their own learning[4].
In a 2009 study, pigs who spent five hours with a mirror learned what the reflection shows[5], and seven of eight used it to find a hidden bowl of food[5]. Pigs without that experience searched behind the mirror[5].
Hens tell their flock-mates apart[6], around 100 of them by classic estimates, and they react when their chicks are in trouble[7]. In a 2011 study, mother hens whose chicks got a mild puff of air became more alert, preened less and showed a drop in eye temperature[7], a physiological sign of stress, even though nothing touched the hens themselves[7].
Bluestreak cleaner wrasse, a small reef fish, try to scrape off a mark they can only see in a mirror[8], a result reported in PLOS Biology in 2019 and backed up by a 2022 follow-up[8]. Rainbow trout have pain receptors like ours[9], and morphine reduces their pain-related behavior[10].
Several of these studies are small. The mirror studies in pigs and fish used only a handful of animals, and the calf-call and heifer studies are observational[3][4][5][8]. But they agree with each other, and with the conclusions of the two separate groups of scientists who reviewed the field.
Harming them is a choice
If there’s a realistic possibility that a fish can suffer[2], and strong evidence that a cow or a hen can[1][2], then what we do to these animals is done to someone, and it has to be judged that way. Treating them as objects means ignoring the science, and nobody has to do it. We don’t need to eat animals to live, so we could stop harming them.
Sources
[1]Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness
Francis Crick Memorial Conference, 2012
[2]New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness
NYU, 2024
[3]Mother-offspring recognition in cows
Animal Behaviour, 2016
[4]Hagen & Broom, 2004
Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2004
[5]Broom, 2009
Animal Behaviour, 2009
[6]Thinking chickens
Animal Cognition, 2017
[7]Edgar et al., 2011
Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 2011
[8]Cleaner wrasse mirror
PLOS Biology, 2019
[9]Sneddon et al., 2003
Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 2003
[10]Morphine as analgesic in trout
Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2003