Taste
The flavors people love in meat come from plants
By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com
Most of what people love about the taste of meat gets added in the kitchen, and all of it is vegan: salt, herbs, spices, sauces, smoke and garlic. Without those, meat is mostly bland[1]. The same seasonings work on tofu and seitan, which people have eaten in place of meat for centuries (tofu for more than 2,000 years)[4][6]. And in blind tests, the best modern plant-based meats score as well as or better than the animal versions[8].
Most of the flavor comes from seasoning
The Institute of Medicine’s 2010 report on reducing sodium found that added salt makes almost every food people eat taste better, even foods that would otherwise taste bad[1]. Without it, food often tastes off[1]. Salt is the usual bare-minimum seasoning on meat[1], and you can put it on anything.
The savory taste people associate with meat has plant sources too[2]. A 2024 review of umami in meat by Hossain and colleagues, in Food Science of Animal Resources, found that salt-curing and spices raise the levels of the savory compounds people think of as meaty[2]. The same review lists tomatoes and mushrooms among the best plant sources of glutamate, the main umami molecule[2].
Wang and colleagues tested this in a 2019 study in the Journal of Food Science[3]. They added mushroom, tomato and yeast extracts to soup, and each one boosted overall flavor, meaty flavor, saltiness and umami, the job salt and MSG usually do[3]. It was only one dish in a lab[3], but it shows how much of the “meaty” taste of a meal can come from plants and yeast.
Meat substitutes are more than 2,000 years old
A 2022 review of Asian meat substitutes by Ishaq and colleagues says China developed tofu as a standard stand-in for meat during the Han dynasty (206 BCE–220 CE), and people kept eating it widely through the Tang dynasty[4]. Legend credits Prince Liu An with inventing it, and FoodUnfolded’s history of meat alternatives notes that Han-dynasty tomb art is thought to show tofu being made[5].
Tofu wasn’t the only one[6]. A 2021 review in Sustainability by He and colleagues names tofu, tempeh and wheat gluten as the first generation of meat substitutes: tofu from China, tempeh (fermented whole soybeans) from Java, and seitan, called miànjīn in Chinese, literally “wheat meat,” from Chinese Buddhist cooking[4][6]. Buddhism created demand in China for substitutes that copied the flavors and textures of meat[5]. CNN Travel, in a piece headlined “China’s vegetarian fake meat is 1,000 years old,” describes temple kitchens that have served mock duck, mock pork and mock fish made from tofu and gluten for centuries[7]. All of this came centuries, even millennia, before modern supermarket products[6].
The best plant-based meats matched meat in blind tests
In 2025, Nectar ran blind tests in restaurants where omnivores tasted 122 plant-based meats in 14 categories[8]. A product counted as a winner if at least half the tasters rated it the same as or better than the animal version[8]. Impossible and Beyond dominated the winners, and several products were nearly indistinguishable from the animal original[8]. Sentient Media’s report on the tests counted four vegan products that scored almost the same as real meat, and found that the products that tasted better also sold more[9].
Not every product matched meat[8], but the ones designed to match it often did[8]. So whatever gap is left comes down to recipe and product design, not something only an animal can supply. These were tasting panels in restaurants rather than controlled lab trials[8], and results vary from product to product[8].
Ratings often drop when people know it’s plant-based
What people expect changes what they taste[10]. In a 2022 study in Food Quality and Preference, Grasso and colleagues had consumers rate burgers that were 100% beef, 100% plant-based, or a hybrid of the two[10]. Knowing what they were eating changed their scores[10]. Ratings often drop when people know a burger is plant-based, and when they don’t know, they’re less loyal to meat. So some of what people think they taste in a cow-flesh burger is really just the label[10].
Plant-based versions go far beyond burgers
A 2023 systematic review by Appiani and colleagues, in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, found plant-based versions of meat, dairy, fish and eggs, covering the whole plate[11]. There are vegan sandwiches, pizza, sushi, ice cream and scrambled eggs. Whether people accept them comes down to appearance, smell, taste and texture, and all four can be designed[11].
Nearly all the flavor people love in meat comes from plants and seasonings, and a well-made vegan meal can deliver it[1][2][3][8]. Going vegan means dropping the habit of tying that flavor to an animal, not giving up the flavor.
Sources
[1]IOM, salt and flavor
IOM, Strategies to Reduce Sodium Intake, 2010
[2]Hossain et al., umami
Food Science of Animal Resources, 2024
[3]Wang et al., 2019
Journal of Food Science, 2019
[4]Ishaq et al., 2022
Food Science of Animal Resources / PMC, 2022
[5]FoodUnfolded
FoodUnfolded
[6]He et al., Sustainability
Sustainability, 2021
[7]CNN, temple mock meats
CNN Travel
[8]Nectar, 2025
Nectar, 2025
[9]Sentient Media
Sentient Media
[10]Grasso et al., 2022
Food Quality and Preference, 2022
[11]Appiani et al., 2023
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 2023