Evolution

The human body was not built to hunt

By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com

No part of the human body can bring down a large animal and open it up[1][2]. Our nails are thin and flat, and they can’t get through fur, hide, feathers or connective tissue[1]. Next to a cat’s, our teeth are short and blunt[1]. A lion can kill a deer and eat it using nothing but its own body[2], while a person needs a sharpened edge, a weapon[2] and, in practice, a fire[3]. Look at our jaws, our eyes, our skin and even the way people react to a dead body, and you keep finding the same animal: a primate that forages for plants by day and learned to make tools.

Our teeth, jaws and nails can’t open a hide

Milton Mills, a physician who has compared how different mammals are built to eat, lays out the differences[1]. A cat has carnassials, blade-like cheek teeth that slice through flesh and tendon like scissors, and its jaw is a hinge that moves up and down with almost no sideways play[1]. In humans, the jaw joint is set above the row of teeth, and a disc lets the lower jaw slide forward and from side to side, which is how our molars crush and grind[1]. Our incisors are spade-shaped[1]. Our canines are small and blunt and work more like extra incisors[1]. Our molars are squarish, bumpy and packed close together, more like grinding stones than blades[1]. Where a cat has claws, we have flat nails[1].

Mills’s comparison matches what dentists see every day[1]. Our mouths are built to pulp plants, and they can’t shear through a hide[1].

We need tools to kill animals and fire to eat them

People can and do eat meat, so the real question is how much of the job our bodies can do on their own. The Smithsonian’s Human Origins program notes that early humans used stone tools for more than 2 million years to cut, pound and crush food, including meat from large animals[2]. Wooden spears for killing large animals show up around 500,000 years ago[2]. People often cite those dates as proof that we were meant to eat meat, but what they really show is how much equipment the job took[2]. Without a manufactured edge, a person can’t open a hide, and without a spear, a person can’t take down a cow[2].

Eating the animal took even more technology[3]. The biological anthropologist Richard Wrangham treats cooking as a human biological trait[3]. Many plant foods are too fibrous to eat raw[3], and most raw meat is too tough to chew easily[3]. Heat is what made flesh manageable for our teeth[3]. Then there’s flavor. The Institute of Medicine’s 2010 report on sodium says added salt makes nearly every food people eat taste better[4], and that without it, food often tastes bad[4]. Meat with no seasoning is mostly bland[3][4], and the herbs, spices and sauces that do the rest of the work are plants[3], the same ones used to season meat substitutes.

Our eyes and skin are built for foraging by day

Humans, apes and Old World monkeys can see reds and greens[5]. In a 2001 paper in Nature, Dominy and Lucas argued that this three-color vision helps primates find ripe fruit and young red leaves against a green canopy[5]. Dogs see the world differently[6]. In behavioral tests, Neitz, Geist and Jacobs found that dogs have two types of cones instead of three, which gives them blue-yellow color vision without the red-green contrast we use to spot a berry[6]. Cats are similar[6]. So carnivores do see some color, just not the way a primate sees fruit[6]. We also lack a tapetum lucidum, the reflective layer behind the retina that gives cats and dogs eyeshine and better night vision[7]. Haplorhine primates, the group we belong to, are active by day and sleep through the dark[7].

The whites of our eyes are another clue. Human sclera is unusually white and exposed, so anyone nearby can tell where we’re looking[9]. Kobayashi and Kohshima described this[9], and Michael Tomasello’s cooperative-eye hypothesis holds that it helps people share attention and work together[8]. A 2022 study in eLife by Kano and colleagues found that uniformly white sclera helps both humans and chimpanzees tell where others are looking[9]. A predator stalking prey is better off hiding where it’s looking, and humans make it obvious[9].

We cool off like foragers too[10]. Humans shed heat through eccrine sweat glands spread across the skin, a trait that Best and Kamilar (Journal of Human Evolution, 2018) trace back to the catarrhine primates and find expanded in us[10]. Dogs and cats have few of these glands and cool down by panting, evaporating water from the tongue and mouth[10]. The other well-known sweaters are horses and some other primates, and both eat plants[10]. Sweating all over suits an animal that keeps moving through the heat of the day while it gathers food[10].

Forward-facing eyes and canine teeth, the two traits people most often point to as signs of a hunter, are ordinary primate features. Every monkey and ape has forward-facing eyes, and gorillas, geladas and orangutans have canines far bigger than ours while living on leaves, grass and fruit[12].

Most people wouldn’t kill an animal with their own hands

Ask people whether they would hurt a dog, a cow or a chicken with their own hands, and most say no[14]. In a 2023 Pew Research Center survey, 97% of U.S. pet owners said their pets are part of the family, and about half said their pets are as much a part of it as a human member[13]. The psychologists Loughnan, Bastian and Haslam (Current Directions in Psychological Science, 2014) call the conflict between caring about animals and eating them the “meat paradox”[14]. People handle it through motivated disengagement: they deny the animal a mind, keep its body out of sight and rename the dead animal as food[14].

To most people, a carcass doesn’t look or smell like dinner[14]. It takes a butcher, a stove[3] and a new name[14] before it does, and without a weapon, most of us couldn’t take the animal down in the first place[2]. A lot of people’s appetite for steak depends on someone else doing the killing and rinsing off the blood.

Sources