Carbon
Vegan diets have about a 75% smaller climate footprint
By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com
A vegan diet produces about 75% less greenhouse gas than a diet heavy in meat[1][9]. Scarborough and colleagues found this in a 2023 study in Nature Food, which took the diets of about 55,000 people in the UK and worked out the environmental cost of what each person ate[1]. Vegans had the lowest impact on every measure the researchers tracked[1]. Compared with people eating 100 grams of meat a day or more, vegan diets also caused about 73% less water pollution[1] and used about 75% less land[1].
Animal foods cause most food emissions
Producing food causes about 26% of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions, according to Our World in Data, and most of that comes from animals and their feed[2][4]. In a 2021 paper in Nature Food, Xu and colleagues broke down the global food system’s emissions: about 57% came from animal-based foods, counting the crops grown to feed the animals, and about 29% from plant-based foods[3]. Poore and Nemecek’s 2018 meta-analysis in Science found that meat and dairy provide about 18% of the world’s calories and about 37% of its protein, yet they produce about 60% of agriculture’s greenhouse gases[4]. Animal foods cause about twice the emissions of plant foods[3] while feeding people far less.
Poore and Nemecek pulled together data on food production from all over the world, and they concluded that avoiding meat and dairy is the single biggest way to cut the climate, land and water impact of what you eat, bigger than buying local or organic[4].
Methane, manure and cleared forests
To eat animals, we first have to grow plants for them, and the animals turn most of those calories into body heat, manure and methane. Methane traps far more heat than carbon dioxide, and cows release it as they digest. Manure gives off more greenhouse gases as it breaks down. The feed needs land too: about 80% of agricultural land is taken up by pasture and feed crops[5], and a lot of that land was forest before it was cleared, which released the carbon stored in the trees and soil. Eating plants directly skips all of those steps. There’s no methane from digestion, no manure lagoon and no extra field of feed, which is why the gap between vegan and high-meat diets is so wide[1].
Buying local barely helps
“Buy local” is one of the most common pieces of green advice, and for most meals it barely changes anything[6]. Our World in Data’s analysis of food emissions shows that what you eat, plants or animals, matters more than how far the food traveled[6]. Transport is a small part of most foods’ footprint[6]. Most of the emissions come from how the food was produced.
Raising an animal takes so much that the distance to the store hardly registers[6]. A dairy cow can drink over 40 gallons of water a day, according to the University of Nebraska-Lincoln[7], and North Dakota State University’s extension service puts cows at roughly 20 to 50 gallons a day, depending on heat, size and whether they’re producing milk[8]. Cows can eat over 100 pounds of plant food a day[10], and all of it has to be grown before the animal is ever loaded onto a truck. A cow digesting grass releases methane whether the farm is in the next valley or on another continent, and the land cleared for its pasture released its carbon either way.
Plants need very little by comparison, and farm animals are fed plants anyway. Vegan food shipped from the other side of the world is still far more efficient than an animal raised and killed locally[6]. The main exception is food sent by air freight, which has a much bigger transport footprint than food moved by ship or truck. Even then, the gap between one vegetable and another is small next to the gap between plant foods and meat.
The UK study is observational
Scarborough’s study is observational[1]. The researchers matched what people said they ate with environmental data for each food, so they didn’t measure the emissions from anyone’s actual plate, and the study covers only one country[1]. Its headline comparison is with high-meat eaters[1], so someone who already eats less meat would see a smaller cut by going vegan. The study’s other groups (lower meat eaters, fish eaters and vegetarians) came out in between[1]. Yale Environment 360’s write-up of the paper reported the same ranking[9].
Global studies back up the UK result[3]. Xu’s breakdown and Poore and Nemecek’s meta-analysis use different methods and data from the UK study, and both put animal foods at the top of the food system’s emissions[3][4]. What you put on your plate is one of the biggest climate decisions most people make every day, and you can change it at your next meal.
Sources
[1]Scarborough et al., Nature Food
Nature Food, 2023
[2]OWID, environmental impacts of food
Our World in Data
[3]Xu et al., Nature Food
Nature Food, 2021
[4]Poore & Nemecek, Science
Science, 2018
[5]OWID, half of habitable land
Our World in Data
[6]OWID, food miles
Our World in Data
[7]UNL, dairy cow water
University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension
[8]NDSU, cow water intake
NDSU Extension
[9]Yale e360 digest
Yale Environment 360
[10]Dairy Cattle Extension, daily feed intake
Dairy Cattle Extension