Hormones

Vegan men have the same free testosterone as meat-eaters

By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com

Vegan men don’t have lower testosterone[1][2]. In the larger of two studies, which compared 696 men who were meat-eaters, vegetarians or vegans, the 233 vegan men had higher total testosterone than either of the other groups[1].

The vegans also had more sex hormone-binding globulin[1], a protein that carries testosterone in the blood and keeps it inactive while it’s bound. The extra binding canceled out the extra testosterone, so free testosterone, the part available to act on the body’s tissues, came out the same in all three groups[1].

An earlier study found the same thing

In 1990, researchers compared 51 vegan men with 57 omnivores[2]. The vegans had 7% higher total testosterone and 23% more binding globulin, which left their free testosterone and estradiol effectively unchanged[2]. That study was small, but a decade later the much larger 2000 study, published in the British Journal of Cancer, found the same thing[1][2].

The 2000 study did turn up one real difference: the vegan men had 9% lower IGF-1[1], a growth factor that promotes cell growth. Higher levels of IGF-1 are linked with higher risk of some cancers. Both studies are observational. They looked at men who were already vegan, vegetarian or meat-eaters, without switching anyone’s diet.

Soy doesn’t change men’s hormones

Most of the worry is about soy. Soy contains isoflavones, plant compounds with a weak estrogen-like structure, and the claim is that tofu or soy milk will lower a man’s testosterone or raise his estrogen. Researchers have tested this directly, many times[3][4]. A 2021 meta-analysis in Reproductive Toxicology pooled 41 clinical studies in men[3]. Neither soy protein nor isoflavones changed total testosterone, free testosterone, estradiol, estrone or binding globulin, at any dose or for any length of time tested[3].

An earlier meta-analysis, published in Fertility and Sterility in 2010, found the same[4]. It pooled 15 placebo-controlled treatment groups and looked at 36 more in simpler models[4]. Soy protein and isoflavones didn’t change men’s testosterone, free testosterone, binding globulin or free androgen index[4].

Unlike the diet comparisons, these were clinical studies: men were given soy or isoflavones, and then their hormones were measured[3][4]. Across both analyses and dozens of trials, nothing supports the claim that soy feminizes men[3][4].

Sources