Heart

Vegans have the lowest risk of heart disease

By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com

Vegans and vegetarians have the lowest risk of heart disease of any diet group studied[1][2]. Long-running cohorts have found this[6][7], and so have pooled analyses of dozens of studies[1][2][3]. Randomized trials show these diets lower the blood fats that drive the disease[9][10][11]. The one exception is stroke: EPIC-Oxford, a large British study, found more of it among vegetarians and vegans[6].

The biggest studies find less heart disease

The broadest look comes from a 2023 umbrella review in Nutrients, which pooled the meta-analyses of both cohorts and trials[1]. People on vegetarian and vegan diets had 29% less cardiovascular disease[1], a 32% lower risk of dying from ischemic heart disease[1] and 33% less ischemic stroke[1]. The authors point out that the quality and consistency of the evidence vary from one outcome to the next[1].

A 2020 umbrella review in Clinical Nutrition covered twenty meta-analyses and 34 health outcomes[2]. Compared with omnivorous diets, vegetarian diets came with total cholesterol 0.55 mmol/L lower[2] and LDL 0.47 mmol/L lower[2], plus a lower risk of ischemic heart disease, diabetes and cancer[2]. The same review found worse one-carbon metabolism, which is why vegans take B12 supplements[2].

Pooled analyses in the European Journal of Nutrition put vegan and vegetarian diets at lower risk of cardiovascular disease[3], ischemic heart disease and stroke[3]. Two reviews of the cardiometabolic research came to the same conclusion: next to mixed diets, vegan and vegetarian diets come with less ischemic heart disease[4], and fully plant-based diets show the healthiest blood fats, blood pressure and body fat[5].

The largest single cohort is EPIC-Oxford, which followed 48,188 people in Britain for 18 years[6]. Vegetarians and vegans had 22% less ischemic heart disease than meat eaters[6], or 10 fewer cases per 1,000 people over a decade[6].

People often argue that those who skip meat are healthier in other ways, so the diet gets credit it hasn’t earned. Seventh-day Adventists are a good test of that, because as a group they already avoid many other risky habits[7]. Even in that health-conscious group, the Adventist Health Study found that the ones who ate no meat had lower death rates from ischemic heart disease[7].

Outside the West, the Indian Migration Study found that vegetarians had lower total cholesterol, triglycerides, LDL cholesterol and diastolic blood pressure than non-vegetarians[8]. Their rates of diabetes and high blood pressure were no different, though[8].

Plant-based diets lower cholesterol in trials

Cohort studies can only show that a diet and a disease go together. Trials assign people to a diet and measure what changes. A 2023 meta-analysis in the European Heart Journal pooled 30 randomized trials comparing plant-based with omnivorous diets[9]. The plant-based diets lowered total cholesterol by 0.34 mmol/L[9], LDL by 0.30 mmol/L[9] and apolipoprotein B by 12.9 mg/dL[9]. Triglycerides didn’t change[9]. The effect was consistent across ages, continents, trial lengths and health status[9].

LDL and apolipoprotein B measure the particles that build plaque in artery walls, which is why these trial results matter more than any single cohort[9]. An earlier analysis of eleven trials, published in the Journal of the American Heart Association in 2015, found that vegetarian diets lowered total, LDL, HDL and non-HDL cholesterol, and again triglycerides didn’t change[10]. A 2017 analysis in Nutrition Reviews combined observational studies with controlled trials lasting four weeks or more, and found lower total, LDL and HDL cholesterol on vegetarian and vegan diets than on the diets they were compared with[11].

Plant-based eating also works in everyday life, away from a metabolic ward. In the BROAD study, a randomized trial run in the community, people with obesity, ischemic heart disease or type 2 diabetes ate a whole-food plant-based diet without counting calories[12]. After six months they had lost about 12 kg, their BMI and cholesterol had improved, and their HbA1c had dropped[12]. Two of the people with diabetes no longer met the threshold for a diagnosis[12].

Fat is a big part of how this works. In a 2017 presidential advisory, the American Heart Association reported that trials which cut saturated fat and replaced it with polyunsaturated vegetable oil reduced cardiovascular disease by about 30%, close to what statin drugs achieve[13].

What people eat instead of meat matters too. A 2019 meta-analysis of 36 trials in Circulation found that when all the comparison diets were lumped together, red meat looked no different from them[14]. But when the researchers sorted the trials by what replaced the red meat, high-quality plant protein lowered total and LDL cholesterol[14], while fish or refined carbohydrates didn’t[14].

Eggs and chickens aren’t a safe swap either

A lot of people who cut back on red meat eat more eggs and chicken flesh instead, but the evidence doesn’t back that up. A meta-analysis found that the more eggs people ate, the higher their risk of both cardiovascular disease and diabetes[15]. A 2019 study in JAMA pooled six US cohorts, with 29,615 people followed for a median of 17.5 years[16]. Each extra half egg a day came with 6% more cardiovascular disease[16] and an 8% higher risk of dying from any cause[16], and the link with eggs came down to dietary cholesterol[16].

A 2022 study in Circulation followed 27,078 men in the Finnish ATBC cohort and counted 22,035 deaths[17]. Each extra 300 mg of dietary cholesterol a day came with a 10% higher risk of dying from any cause and a 13% higher risk of dying from cardiovascular disease, and each extra 50 g of egg a day, about one egg, came with 6% and 9% higher risks[17]. An updated meta-analysis in the same paper is separate from that death count: across 3,601,401 people, each extra 50 g of egg a day came with about 4% more cardiovascular disease[17]. Randomized trials agree: eating more eggs raised LDL cholesterol by about 8 mg/dL and worsened the LDL-to-HDL ratio, and the effects were larger in trials that ran longer than two months[18].

Researchers used the same six US cohorts to look at chicken and turkey flesh, following 29,682 adults for a median of 19 years[19]. For each additional two servings a week, processed meat came with 7% more cardiovascular disease[19], unprocessed red meat with 3% more[19], and chicken and turkey flesh with 4% more[19]. Fish showed no link either way[19], and only the red meats were linked to dying sooner[19]. The authors call the increases small[19]. Because this analysis draws on the same cohorts as the 2019 egg study, the two aren’t independent confirmations of each other[19].

EPIC-Oxford found more strokes

EPIC-Oxford, the same study that found 22% less ischemic heart disease, also found 20% more total stroke among vegetarians and vegans[6], or 3 more strokes per 1,000 people over a decade[6], against 10 fewer cases of heart disease[6]. Most of the extra strokes were hemorrhagic, the kind caused by bleeding in the brain[6]. The authors couldn’t rule out lower B12 or lower cholesterol as the cause, and almost everyone in the study was white British[6]. Other pooled studies found less stroke on these diets[1][3], including the 33% less ischemic stroke in the 2023 umbrella review[1], but that doesn’t cancel out the EPIC-Oxford result[6].

Most of the research on heart disease itself is observational, and a cohort can never fully separate a diet from the kind of people who choose it. The trials on LDL and apolipoprotein B don’t have that weakness, and they agree with the cohorts: less animal food means less of the cholesterol that clogs arteries[9][10][11], and less heart disease[1][6].

Sources