Weight
Vegans have the lowest risk of obesity
By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com
In studies of diet and body weight, vegans keep coming out as the leanest group, with the lowest risk of obesity of any diet studied[1]. Randomized trials back this up: when people are put on a vegan diet, often with no instruction to eat less[5][8], they lose weight[4][5][6][7][8][9].
Less obesity in vegans, more in meat eaters
A review in Obesity Reviews found vegan diets linked with the lowest risk of obesity[1]. The reasons are ordinary. Vegan meals have more fiber, the foods are less calorie-dense, and they leave out the heavy fat that comes with animal products. In a randomized trial in JAMA Network Open, 22 pairs of identical twins were split between a healthy vegan diet and a healthy omnivorous diet for 8 weeks, and the vegan twins lost more weight[2]. Losing weight doesn’t require animal products[4][5][7][8], and it often means getting fewer calories from them.
On the meat side, a meta-analysis covering 1,135,661 people (Obesity Reviews, 2014) found that eating more red and processed meat came with 37% higher odds of obesity[3], along with a higher BMI and a bigger waist at the top of the intake range[3].
People lose weight on vegan diets in trials
Observational studies can’t rule out that leaner people are just more likely to choose a vegan diet. Randomized trials get around that by assigning the diet. A 2016 meta-analysis of 12 randomized trials (Journal of General Internal Medicine) found that people assigned a vegetarian diet lost 2.0 kg more than those on non-vegetarian diets, over a median of 18 weeks[4]. On vegan diets the difference was 2.5 kg[4]. A 2015 meta-analysis in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics found that prescribing vegetarian diets, vegan ones included, lowered average body weight[5], even in trials where weight loss wasn’t the stated goal[5].
A 2022 pool of 11 trials lasting 12 weeks or longer, in people with overweight or type 2 diabetes, found that vegan diets cut body weight by 4.1 kg and BMI by 1.4[6]. HbA1c fell 0.18 points[6], total cholesterol 0.30 mmol/L[6] and LDL 0.24 mmol/L[6]. Blood pressure and triglycerides didn’t change[6].
Single trials have found bigger effects[7][8]. In a 16-week randomized trial of overweight adults (Nutrition & Diabetes, 2018), the low-fat vegan group lost 6.5 kg[7], 4.3 kg of it fat[7], while the control group showed no significant change[7]. Visceral fat, the fat packed around the organs, fell only in the vegan group[7], and so did HOMA-IR, a measure of insulin resistance[7]. In the BROAD community trial, people with obesity, ischemic heart disease or type 2 diabetes ate a whole-food plant-based diet without counting calories[8], and at six months they were about 12 kg lighter[8], with better BMI and cholesterol[8].
The body burns more calories digesting the food
Part of the explanation is what goes on the plate: fiber fills people up on fewer calories. A 16-week randomized trial of 244 overweight adults (JAMA Network Open, 2020) found a second reason[9]. The trial left out people who already had diabetes[9]. On a low-fat vegan diet, body weight fell 5.9 kg[9], and the thermic effect of food, the calories the body burns digesting a meal, rose 14%[9]. The same diet cut liver fat by 34%[9] and fat inside muscle by 10%[9], and insulin sensitivity improved[9]. None of these changed in the control group[9].
A 14% rise means the body spent more energy handling the same meals after the switch[7]. It’s a modest effect on any single day, but it happens every day, and it helps explain why people on vegan diets lose weight without counting calories. The drop in liver and muscle fat matters beyond the scale, because fat stored in those tissues is closely tied to insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes[7].
Most trials were short
The cohort studies are observational, and most trials ran for weeks or months, with a median of 18 weeks in the 12-trial pool[4]. The pooled differences of 2 to 4 kg are smaller than the results of the strongest single trials[4][6][7][8], and in the 2022 pool, blood pressure and triglycerides didn’t change[6]. Still, the trials agree: taking animal products off the plate lowers body weight[4][5][6][7][8][9], whether or not weight loss was the aim[5].
Sources
[1]Obesity Reviews
Obesity Reviews
[2]JAMA Network Open
JAMA Network Open
[3]Obesity Reviews, 2014
Obesity Reviews, 2014
[4]12 trials, 2016
Journal of General Internal Medicine, 2016
[5]Barnard meta-analysis
Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 2015
[6]11 trials, 2022
Obesity Reviews, 2022
[7]Kahleova, 2018
Nutrition & Diabetes, 2018
[8]BROAD study
Nutrition & Diabetes, 2017
[9]JAMA Network Open, 2020
JAMA Network Open, 2020