Diabetes
Vegans have the lowest risk of type 2 diabetes
By WhyStopHarmingAnimals.com
Vegans have the lowest rates of type 2 diabetes of any diet group researchers have tracked[1][2][3][4]. Vegetarians have more than vegans, and people who eat meat have more still[1]. The more meat people eat, the more type 2 diabetes they get[5][6][7], and that’s true of unprocessed red meat as well as bacon and sausages[5][6][8].
Adventist vegans had the least diabetes
The cleanest comparisons come from Seventh-day Adventists, many of whom avoid meat for religious reasons but otherwise live much the same way[1][2]. Among 60,903 Adventists, type 2 diabetes went up with each step toward more animal food: 2.9% of vegans had it, 3.2% of lacto-ovo vegetarians, 4.8% of pesco-vegetarians, 6.1% of semi-vegetarians and 7.6% of non-vegetarians (Diabetes Care, 2009)[1]. Even after the researchers adjusted for body mass index, vegans had about half the risk of non-vegetarians, so lower weight doesn’t explain the whole gap[1].
When the Adventist Health Study-2 went on to count new cases of diabetes, in a report in the American Journal of Epidemiology, vegans again had the lowest risk of any diet group[2]. A review of vegetarian diets found the same, with vegan diets linked to the fewest new cases of type 2 diabetes[3], and a more recent analysis of plant-based diets and type 2 diabetes again found the lowest risk in vegans[4].
More meat, more diabetes
Meta-analyses that measure how much meat people eat find a dose-response: the more meat, the higher the risk[5][7]. The largest of these pooled 31 cohorts from 20 countries, covering 1.97 million adults (The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, 2024)[5]. Each daily 100 g of unprocessed red meat came with 10% more type 2 diabetes[5], each 50 g of processed meat with 15% more[5], and each 100 g of chicken and turkey flesh with 8% more[5]. People often see chicken flesh as the safe alternative to cow flesh, but in this analysis it raised the risk too[5].
An earlier meta-analysis of 12 cohorts, published in Diabetologia in 2009, compared the heaviest meat eaters with the lightest[6]. Red meat came with 21% more type 2 diabetes[6], and processed meat with 41% more[6]. A separate dose-response meta-analysis of meat and fish found that type 2 diabetes risk rose in a straight line with total meat, red meat and processed meat[7]. A systematic review found that unprocessed and processed red meat were both linked to a higher risk of diabetes and of cardiovascular disease[8], and a review of meat as a risk factor for diabetes found the link consistent across the research[9].
People defending meat usually blame the salt and preservatives in processed products. But unprocessed red meat and chicken and turkey flesh raised the risk too, just by less per gram[5].
It matters what replaces the meat
Cutting out meat only helps if what replaces it is real food[10]. The largest study on this followed 200,727 people in the Nurses’ Health Studies and the Health Professionals Follow-Up Study, with two decades of diet records (PLOS Medicine, 2016)[10]. People whose diets were the most plant-based had 20% less type 2 diabetes[10]. On a version of the score that rewarded healthy plant foods, the drop was 34%[10]. A version weighted toward juice, soda, refined grains and sweets raised the risk instead[10]. A diet can leave out meat and still be built on sugar, and that kind of diet doesn’t protect anyone[10].
A 2017 analysis that ranked twelve food groups (European Journal of Epidemiology) rated the evidence “high” that red and processed meat raise the risk of type 2 diabetes, along with sugary drinks[11]. Whole grains and fruit were protective[11], and eating the protective foods in optimal amounts came with 42% lower risk[11]. Dairy also came with lower risk in the same analysis[11], which doesn’t match the results for other animal foods, so it counts as a mixed finding.
Why vegans get less diabetes
Weight is part of it. Vegan diets are linked with the lowest obesity risk of the diets studied[12], largely because they have more fiber and fewer calorie-dense foods. But the Adventist vegans still had about half the risk after adjusting for body mass index, so something besides weight is going on[1].
A 16-week randomized trial of 244 overweight adults offers one clue[13]. The trial left out people who already had diabetes[13]. On a low-fat vegan diet, fat stored inside the liver fell 34% and fat inside muscle fell 10%[13], and insulin sensitivity improved[13], while none of it changed in the control group (JAMA Network Open, 2020)[13]. Fat stored inside muscle cells gets in the way of insulin signaling, so clearing it out lets insulin work better.
The prevention studies are observational
The research on preventing type 2 diabetes comes from cohorts, which adjust for known differences such as body weight. But nobody can randomize thousands of people to eat meat or not for twenty years, so some confounding may remain. Dairy is a genuine exception in one large analysis[11].
Even so, the findings are hard to dismiss because they fit together: a step-by-step rise across diet groups[1], a dose-response for meat across nearly two million adults[5], the same rise for unprocessed red meat and chicken and turkey flesh[5], and a randomized trial in which insulin sensitivity improved once animal products came off the plate[13].
Sources
[1]Adventist diet groups, Diabetes Care 2009
Diabetes Care, 2009
[2]AHS-2
American Journal of Epidemiology
[3]Vegetarian patterns
PMC
[4]Plant-based T2D
PubMed
[5]Meat and diabetes, 20 countries
The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, 2024
[6]12 cohorts, 21% and 41%
Diabetologia, 2009
[7]Dose-response meta
PubMed
[8]Red meat, CVD, diabetes
PubMed
[9]Meat as T2D risk
PMC
[10]Plant-based diet scores, PLOS Medicine 2016
PLOS Medicine, 2016
[11]Twelve food groups
European Journal of Epidemiology, 2017
[12]Obesity Reviews
Obesity Reviews
[13]JAMA Network Open, 2020
JAMA Network Open, 2020