Kidneys

Kidneys

Red meat is linked with kidney failure, and plant-based diets with healthier kidneys

40%More kidney failure in the top quarter of red-meat eaters

The healthiest plant-based diets come with less chronic kidney disease[1], and red meat is the food most consistently linked with kidney failure[2]. Even among people with high uric acid, a common path to kidney damage, vegans had lower odds of kidney disease[3]. If you cared about your kidneys, you would stop eating animals.

What the evidence says

The main points first. Every claim is tied to a source below.

People on the healthiest plant-based diets got less chronic kidney disease

Researchers followed 14,686 middle-aged adults for a median of 24 years, and 4,343 of them developed chronic kidney disease[1]. Those eating the healthiest plant-based diets had 14% less of it and a slower drop in kidney filtering rate, while those whose diets leaned on less healthy plant foods had 11% more[1]. Among 3,618 people whose uric acid was already high, a known route to kidney damage[2], vegans had 31% lower odds of chronic kidney disease than omnivores, and lacto-ovo vegetarians fell in between[2].

Read full article →

The more red meat people ate, the more kidney failure they had

Among 63,257 adults in Singapore followed for 15.5 years, 951 developed end-stage kidney failure[1]. The quarter who ate the most red meat had 40% more, and the risk rose steadily with the amount eaten[1]. Replacing one daily serving of red meat with another protein source was linked with up to 62% lower risk[1]. Chicken and turkey flesh, fish, eggs, and dairy showed no such link, which points to red meat specifically, not protein in general[1].

Read full article →

Articles

Kidneys do better on plant-based diets and worse with red meat

People on the healthiest plant-based diets get less chronic kidney disease and lose kidney function more slowly, while the more red meat people eat, the more often their kidneys fail.

Read full article →

Sources

Papers and datasets. Each card keeps its caveats, including small samples and single-animal cases.

[1]Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 2019 · Observational

Healthy plant-based diets came with 14% less chronic kidney disease

Researchers followed 14,686 middle-aged adults for a median of 24 years and recorded 4,343 new cases of chronic kidney disease. The healthiest plant-based diets came with 14% less chronic kidney disease and a slower decline in kidney filtering rate, while diets built on less healthy plant foods had 11% more, so the quality of the plant foods mattered.

[2]Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 2017 · Observational

People who ate the most red meat had 40% higher risk of kidney failure

Among 63,257 adults in Singapore followed for 15.5 years, 951 developed end-stage kidney failure. The top quarter of red-meat eaters had 40% higher risk, and the risk rose steadily with the amount eaten. Chicken and turkey flesh, fish, eggs, and dairy showed no link, and replacing one daily serving of red meat with another protein source came with up to 62% lower risk.

[3]Nutrients, 2023 · Observational

Vegans with high uric acid had 31% lower odds of chronic kidney disease

Among 3,618 patients with hyperuricemia (high uric acid, a known route to kidney damage), vegans had 31% lower odds of chronic kidney disease than omnivores after adjustment, with lacto-ovo vegetarians in between. The study was cross-sectional, a single snapshot, so it can’t say which came first.